The 7-Step Checklist I Run Before Approving Any Woodworking Tool Order
-
When this checklist applies
-
1. Write down the cut and the material before you open a catalog
-
2. Confirm shank size and collet compatibility
-
3. Answer the impact driver question before you buy driver bits
-
4. Price router bits on cost-per-cut, not sticker price
-
5. Standardize your small tool kits to one part number
-
6. Let the workflow pick the tool cart
-
7. Ask the vendor what they're not good at
-
Notes and common mistakes
-
1. Write down the cut and the material before you open a catalog
When this checklist applies
I'm the procurement manager for a 28-person millwork shop. Six years ago I started tracking every tool and consumable invoice in our system; as of Q1 2025 that adds up to roughly $310,000 in cumulative spending across 40+ vendors.
I built this checklist after our 2023 audit turned up about $6,200 in avoidable tool spending—duplicate bit orders, wrong shank sizes, and two tool carts that never left the loading dock. It's what I run now before I approve any order, whether we're outfitting a new bench or resupplying an existing one. Seven steps, each with a checkpoint. Work through them in order.
1. Write down the cut and the material before you open a catalog
Most bad purchases start on a product page instead of a cut list. Before you look at pricing, write down three things: the material (oak? MDF? plywood?), the profile you need (v-groove, roundover, raised panel), and the depth of cut.
This matters more than people realize. A freud v groove router bit sized for soft maple at 1/4-inch depth is a different tool from what you'd run in oak at 3/8-inch. Same with freud cabinet door router bits—the rail-and-stile geometry has to match the door profile you've actually committed to, not a generic "cabinet" spec. If you can't write the cut down in one sentence, you're not ready to buy.
Checkpoint: You have a written line that reads like "3/8-inch v-groove, 1/4-inch depth, red oak, 6,000 RPM." If you don't, stop.
2. Confirm shank size and collet compatibility
Half the returns I've processed trace back to a 1/4-inch bit in a 1/2-inch collet, or the reverse. Check your router's collet size before anything ships—and if you're buying "for the shop," check every router that might actually run the bit.
For the bits doing heavy work—cabinet door sets especially—I'd argue for 1/2-inch shank wherever the router supports it. Less chatter, cleaner cuts, longer bit life. (Should mention: the resharpening interval also stretches out, which is where most of the real savings live.)
Checkpoint: You've written down which router (make, model, collet) each bit will run on. If a bit can't run on anything in the building, it's not entering the building.
3. Answer the impact driver question before you buy driver bits
So do you need special bits for impact driver use? Yes. This is the one place where "just use what we have" costs more than buying right. Standard driver bits—even good ones—can shatter or cam out under an impact driver's torque, and a chewed screw head means labor you're now paying for twice.
Look for bits explicitly rated for impact drivers (usually marked with a torsion zone or a specific torque rating). The price difference per bit runs about 40-60 cents. The cost of stripping a head on a finished cabinet face is ten minutes of repair and a very unhappy customer.
Checkpoint: The product spec says "impact-rated" or gives a torque number. Not "works with all drivers."
4. Price router bits on cost-per-cut, not sticker price
Here's where I used to get fooled. Two bits, same profile—one at $28, one at $64 (or rather, $68 with shipping, once I stopped pretending shipping was free). I'd take the cheap one. Then the cheap one lost its edge after 40 cabinet doors and the expensive one ran 140 before we sent it out for sharpening.
Run the math: cost divided by cuts-before-resharpening. On cabinet door sets, industrial-tier bits (the Freud industrial line is our benchmark since 2021—not sponsored, just what we've standardized on) usually work out 30-50% cheaper per cut, even at double the sticker price. Your actual number depends on material and feed rate.
I don't have hard data on defect rates across brands, but based on six years of our own invoices, I'd put the industry average of premature bit failures at around 8-12% of first orders. There's something satisfying about a bit that runs 140 doors before you even think about sharpening—that math pays for itself fast.
Checkpoint: You've estimated cuts-before-sharpening for each candidate. If the vendor won't give you a number—and I do mean a specific number, not a range—treat that as a data point too.
5. Standardize your small tool kits to one part number
We used to have six different screwdriver sets scattered across the shop—a "miscellaneous" drawer nobody could find anything in. Then I standardized on one all-in-1 precision screwdriver set with case and put a small bin at each bench. The parts are cheap. The recovery time from "where's the torque screwdriver?" to "here it is" isn't.
The case matters, by the way. An all-in-1 precision screwdriver set with case means the bits are labeled in the same order in every kit. No more guessing which of the eight tiny bits is the T6. (Note to self: don't let anyone repurpose the case for something else. It will disappear.)
Checkpoint: One part number, one case design, one bin per workstation. If there are more than two screwdriver kit SKUs in the shop, you have a problem.
6. Let the workflow pick the tool cart
Tool carts are the most overspec'd thing we buy. Every catalog wants to sell you the rolling mega-cart with eight drawers and a built-in power strip. Usually what the shop actually needs is a smaller, lighter cart that fits down the aisle between benches.
Before you buy anything, walk the actual route: from bit storage to the router station, router station to assembly, assembly to the loading bay. Measure the narrowest gap. Count the doorways. Then buy a tool cart that fits—not one you'll have to unload every time it needs to move.
Checkpoint: You've walked the route with a tape measure. The cart you're about to buy fits the tightest turn with at least four inches of clearance.
7. Ask the vendor what they're not good at
This is the step most people skip. When I was comparing router bit suppliers in early 2022 (circa March 2022, for reference), I asked each sales rep the same question: "What do you not do well?"
Three out of five promised they were great at everything. The other two named specific limits—one said their bits weren't ideal for exotic hardwood at high feed rates, the other said they didn't stock small-diameter down-cut spirals and pointed us to a competitor.
Guess which two we bought from. The vendor who says "this isn't our strength—here's who does it better" isn't telling you they're weak. They're telling you they know their equipment and won't oversell you. That's the trait that ends up saving you the most money over a decade.
Checkpoint: You have a written answer—in email—where the vendor described at least one thing they don't handle well. If you don't, you haven't finished the evaluation.
Notes and common mistakes
A few things I've learned the hard way across 40+ tool vendors:
- Don't buy bits in a "set" unless every size will get used. We bought a 15-piece cabinet door set in 2021 where we've used exactly seven of the bits. The other eight have never left the case.
- Shipping cost is part of TCO. A vendor quoting 8% less than another but shipping UPS Ground on a $2,400 order—do the math before you celebrate.
- Verify current pricing before you commit a budget. The numbers I've referenced here were accurate as of Q1 2025. Steel prices and freight rates move; get a fresh quote before you sign.
- The "free shipping" threshold is a trap (like when the threshold is $500 and you need $480 worth of bits). Add a thing you actually use. Don't add filler.
- Read the resharpening policy. Some "cheap" bit programs charge $8-12 per bit for sharpening, which can flip the TCO math on high-volume runs.
One more thing: the checklist itself has a shelf life. We rebuild it every 18 months as our product mix changes. A great tool purchase today can be an anchor in two years. Verify your numbers, walk your routes, and ask the boundary question before you sign anything.